After the story, I announced that we were going to have our own sandcastle contest and invited the students to use the paper on the desk and only their hands to create their own. And then I joined them.
I asked one of my girls with an empty seat next to her if I could work beside her, and then I proceeded to model appropriate language and strategies for completing the task as I worked. Knowing that so many students are reluctant to even attempt torn paper art, I began with comments like, "Now that is not the shape I was trying to make. I wonder how I could use it a different way?" and (talking aloud to myself) "Oh, no. I am trying to _______, but it's not working. What could I do?". I also model asking to share glue and using superb manners, what to do when pieces of torn paper get mixed up between me and my desk partner, and sharing general techniques such as rolling strips of paper on a pencil or my finger or folding it accordion style for different effects. We discussed how ripping the paper into different shapes and then putting the shapes together could help us reach our goal. Ten or fifteen minutes in, a student asks, "Is this a competition?" "Yes it is, " I answer, "but not in the way that you think." Then five or ten minutes after that I comment "Does everyone's sandcastle look exactly the same?" The general concensus was no. Many students were thoroughly engaged after 30-35 minutes. Two or three of my more active (and normally uninspired) boys were busily creating sand mailboxes (complete with pieces of sand "mail" and sand "guys" opening the mailboxes. Only one student continued to stare at me surrounded by pieces of ripped paper and no idea where to begin designing what I had asked of him.
"Recess time," I said, "we'll finish later today."
A few students remained in their seats working incessantly on their beachy creations. Eventually I coaxed them out. My own sandcastle was coming along nicely, a sand "ladder" allowed visitors to my coastal palace access to two separate towers connected by a sand "rope bridge". A spiral of rolled paper seemed to dance at the apex of the second tower, beckoning outsiders. How could I become more of a participant and facilitator on a daily basis in my students' learning? What would it take?
When the students returned from their break, they settled onto the carpet spots. "Earlier I mentioned that designing our torn paper sandcastles was a contest, but not the kind you'd think," I started, hooking my nearly first graders' attention and then reeling it in bit by bit. Eventually the students deducted that what I meant was they were competing against themselves. That what others created was their own competition and of no matter when they judged their own work. After all, none of them were exactly alike and we can only ever try to do better than our last try, right? Natch. The kids were in. Then one piped up. "But what's the prize?" Aha. The prize. The carrot. The draw. Just out of reach, but so enticing. What would it be this time? A pencil? A sticker? Extra computer time? I smiled softly and said, "We will talk about the prize later on."
And so the kids continued, one girl adding an opening drawbridge and secret windows and clouds that folded down to reveal princesses and dragons; another creating the outline of a pole house reminiscent of an island getaway. One boy showed me how to fold a large triangle into a square but folding two smaller triangles in from the edges. As the kids began to finish, I offered a choice. Students could read, work on a quiet desk activity, or get more blue and tan paper to make another creation. An interesting thing happened. One girl came up to me with a geometric design on her page. At the top of the page a handwritten sentence read: "Find the chryangl in the sercle." Geometric riddles? How many common core standards was I actually addressing here? Without even trying? Just by providing what educators in the progressive movement call a "provocation". Putting out materials and allowing learners to guide themselves. Student-centered learning. How novel. And the geometric riddles caught on like wildfire throughout the classroom. And I sat next to my table partner and watched it all play out.










